The Dynamics of Buybacks for Optimal Returns

I would like to express my sincere gratitude to Mr. Anshuman Rawat for his invaluable guidance and encouragement in selecting me to pen this article, prompted by the expressed interest of our cherished readers in the comments section. In this discourse, I endeavor to delve into the intricate subject of stock buybacks, a corporate maneuver executed by companies to bestow profits upon their shareholders. The essence of a buyback lies in its ability to fortify fundamental health and foster growth. When a company perceives that its intrinsic value surpasses the prevailing market valuation, it convenes a board of directors meeting to officially announce the buyback. I am committed to delivering a comprehensive analysis on this topic, and I welcome constructive feedback from readers to refine and enhance the quality of the content.

The query arises as to why companies opt for share buybacks. The rationale behind this strategic move primarily revolves around providing enhanced returns to shareholders and bolstering the fundamental underpinnings of the company, thereby fostering improved valuation and sustained growth. Additionally, companies may undertake buybacks as a means of managing the delicate balance between their valuation and traded stock prices. There exist two distinct types of buybacks—tender route buyback and market route buyback. Companies typically convene board of director meetings to formally announce the buyback, specifying the percentage and the method of implementation. For instance, if a company’s shares are currently trading at 100 rupees, but the company believes its intrinsic value warrants a 120-rupee valuation, a buyback may be announced at a 20% premium. Moreover, companies may choose to announce buybacks based on a percentage of shareholders’ holdings, such as 20% buyback on 10% of total holdings, ensuring a proportionate approach rather than a complete buyback. This methodology empowers shareholders to selectively participate in the buyback process, aligning with their individual preferences.

Following the execution of a share buyback, the share price undergoes an automatic adjustment, aligning itself with the premium at which the buyback transpired. This adjustment mechanism ensures that shareholders not only benefit from the profits distributed during the buyback but also experience an enhanced return through the appreciation of the share value. It is crucial to comprehend the nuances between the two types of buybacks discussed earlier—tender route buyback and market route buyback. These variants serve distinct purposes within a company’s strategic repertoire. Tender route buybacks involve a direct invitation to shareholders to submit their shares at a specified price, fostering a more targeted approach. On the other hand, market route buybacks are conducted through open market transactions, providing companies with more flexibility in the timing and quantity of share repurchases. The choice between these methods depends on various factors, including regulatory considerations and the company’s specific objectives. Both types, when executed prudently, aim to enhance shareholder value, but preferences may vary based on the company’s circumstances and shareholder interests. In the ensuing discussion, we will delve into the intricacies of these buyback types, exploring the differential impact on shareholders and discerning which approach may be more favorable in specific contexts.

The first type of buyback, known as tender route buyback, involves companies repurchasing their own shares from shareholders and subsequently retiring the acquired shares. This strategic move results in a reduction of the company’s total outstanding shares. While the company’s net profit remains unchanged, the immediate effect is an increase in Earnings Per Share (EPS). To illustrate, consider a scenario where a company has 100 shares with earnings of 200 rupees, resulting in an EPS of 2. If the share price is trading at 20 rupees, the Price-to-Earnings (P/E) ratio stands at 10 (20/2). Subsequently, the company announces a buyback, repurchasing 20% of its shares and retiring them. Post-buyback, the company is left with 80 outstanding shares. With the earnings still at 200 rupees, the new EPS becomes 2.5 (200/80). Consequently, with the share price at 20 rupees, the revised P/E ratio decreases to 8 (20/2.5). This exemplifies how tender route buybacks contribute to an improvement in fundamental metrics, such as EPS, leading to a lower P/E ratio, thereby enhancing shareholder value.

The second type of buyback, termed market route buyback, stands in stark contrast to tender route buyback. In this scenario, a company acquires its own shares from the open market without retiring them. The motivation behind this approach often lies in the need to increase promoter holding, particularly when it is relatively low. While shareholders do not experience immediate direct benefits, the long-term advantages become evident as the company strategically bolsters its holdings. This buyback mechanism serves to diminish the supply of shares available in the open market, subsequently leading to a potential increase in share prices. To illustrate, consider a company with 100 shares, earning 200 rupees, resulting in an EPS of 2 and a P/E ratio of 10 when the share price is at 20 rupees. If promoters initially hold 50% of the shares and the company undertakes a market route buyback, increasing promoter holding to 75%, the outstanding shares in the open market decrease to 25. This reduction in supply elevates demand, leading to a subsequent rise in share prices over time. Although the share price adjusts automatically post-buyback, the fundamentals of the company do not undergo improvement. It is noteworthy that, while market route buybacks can yield profits for shareholders through increased share prices, the more prevalent preference among shareholders often leans towards tender route buybacks due to their direct impact on fundamental metrics and enhanced value creation.

Follow me on Twitter (X) @RawatAnshumaan